In short
Choose ducted reverse cycle if you want one system that heats and cools the whole home through ceiling vents. Choose hydronic if you want quiet, radiant warmth with no air blowing, and you are happy to plan cooling separately.
In a new build, make the call before the slab is poured. Underfloor heating cannot sensibly be added later, and from 1 January 2027 new Victorian homes must be built all-electric, so a gas heater or gas boiler is off the table for most new builds.
Key takeaways
• Ducted reverse cycle heats and cools the whole home from one hidden indoor unit, through a vent in each room.
• Hydronic heating warms rooms with hot water piped to radiators, trench convectors or pipes in the floor.
• From 1 January 2027, new homes in Victoria must be built all-electric, with some exemptions, so hydronic in a new build runs from an electric heat source such as an air-to-water heat pump.
• The Australian Government's YourHome guide notes that in-slab heating is installed during construction and is slow to warm and cool because of the slab's thermal mass.
• Hydronic heats. Ducted reverse cycle heats and cools. That one difference shapes the rest of the decision.
Once the floor plan is settled, most people building in Melbourne reach the heating question and find two very different systems on the table. One moves warm air. The other moves warm water. Both can keep a home comfortable through a Melbourne winter, and neither is the right answer for every house. Here is how to tell which one suits yours.
What is the difference between ducted and hydronic heating?
Ducted reverse cycle heating uses one indoor unit, usually hidden in the ceiling space, with insulated ducts running to a vent in each room and an outdoor unit outside. It heats by blowing warm air into each room, and the same system cools in summer.
Hydronic heating uses a heat source to warm water, which circulates in a closed loop of pipes to the rooms. YourHome describes hydronic systems as circulating hot water through radiator panels in rooms or under the floor. The heat comes off the radiator, the convector or the floor itself, so nothing blows into the room.
You can see how each one is installed on our ducted system and hydronic heating pages. If you are weighing up the different kinds of hydronic, read types of hydronic heating, explained.
How does the all-electric rule change the choice?
From 1 January 2027, Victoria's electrification requirements apply to all new residential buildings, according to Energy Victoria. There are exemptions for situations where electrification is impractical, but for most new builds it rules out gas ducted heating and gas boilers.
Both options are still on the table. Ducted reverse cycle already runs on electricity. Hydronic needs an electric heat source instead of a gas boiler:
• An air-to-water heat pump, which takes heat from the outside air and moves it into the water for your radiators or floor. YourHome describes heat pumps, including reverse cycle air conditioners, as the most energy-efficient combined heating and cooling system you can buy. See our air-to-water systems page.
• An electric boiler, which heats the water directly. See our boilers and thermostats page.
If the standard specification from your builder still shows a gas heater, raise it now. It is far easier to change on paper than on site.
What does each one feel like to live with?
Ducted warms the air, and it can heat a room quickly. How comfortable it feels depends a lot on the design. YourHome notes that warm air rises, so ceiling outlets can leave you with cold feet and a warm head, and that floor outlets are often better for heating. It also says a return air path from every outlet back to the system is important; without one, warm air escapes and cold air is drawn in.
Hydronic warms the surfaces in the room: the radiator, the convector or the floor. There is no air blowing from vents and no fan noise in the room. Radiators and trench convectors heat up far faster than a slab. In-slab underfloor heating is different: YourHome says it is slow to warm and cool because of the slab's thermal mass, and unsuitable for houses where heating is only needed occasionally. It suits a household that is home a lot and wants steady, even warmth.
Which costs more to run, ducted or hydronic?
It depends on the design, the insulation, the heat source and how you use the system, so be wary of anyone who gives you a running cost before they have seen your plans. What we can tell you is what drives the cost of each.
• Ducted: correct sizing for the house, zoning so you only heat the rooms you use, and well-insulated, sealed ducts. YourHome recommends sizing the system for the house and including zoning so heating to unoccupied areas can be shut off.
• Hydronic: the heat source first, then the pipework and controls. YourHome says higher running costs are usually caused by unnecessary water circulation or poor pipe insulation, and recommends insulated pipes, smart controls to manage pump use, and insulated exterior walls behind radiator panels.
• Underfloor: YourHome recommends insulating the slab edges, ideally the whole slab, and says heating zones and thermostats are essential to reduce energy use.
Zoning matters for both. On a ducted system, MyAir zoning lets you switch rooms on and off from your phone. On a hydronic system, each room or zone can be controlled separately.
What about cooling?
This is often the deciding factor. Ducted reverse cycle cools with the same equipment it heats with, so one system covers the whole year.
Hydronic is chosen for heating. YourHome notes that hydronic systems can circulate cold water too, but in a typical home you would plan cooling separately, and a few well-placed split systems or a multi-split is a common pairing. Our guide to ducted vs split system cooling for a new home walks through that choice, and evaporative or refrigerated cooling covers the other option.
When do you have to decide in a new build?
Earlier than most people expect.
• In-slab underfloor heating: before the slab is poured. YourHome notes that in-slab systems are installed during building construction or renovation.
• Trench convectors: before the slab or floor is finished, because the trench they sit in has to be formed. See trench convectors.
• Radiators: before the walls are lined, so pipes can be run to each location. See hydronic radiators.
• Ducted: before the frame and ceilings are lined, so the indoor unit, duct runs and outdoor unit can be planned in.
If you are a builder specifying for a client, see how we work with architects and builders.
A quick way to decide
• Lean ducted if you want heating and cooling from one system, you have good ceiling space, and you are comfortable with warm air heating. Plan the zones with the floor plan.
• Lean hydronic if quiet, even warmth with no air movement matters most, you are home a lot through winter, and you are happy to plan cooling separately. Commit early if you want underfloor.
• Talk it through if your home is two storey, you are considering a mix (underfloor in the living areas and radiators upstairs, for example), or you are not sure which heat source suits your energy supply.
Frequently asked questions
Is ducted or hydronic heating better for a new Melbourne home?
Neither is better in general. Ducted reverse cycle suits homes that want one system to heat and cool every room. Hydronic suits homes that want quiet, radiant warmth with no air blowing, and are happy to plan cooling separately.
Can I still have gas hydronic heating in a new build?
From 1 January 2027, new homes in Victoria must be built all-electric, with some exemptions. In a new build, hydronic heating will usually run from an electric heat source, such as an air-to-water heat pump.
Does hydronic heating also cool?
Hydronic is chosen for heating. YourHome notes that hydronic systems can circulate cold water as well, but in a typical home you would plan cooling separately, often with split systems.
Which is cheaper to run, ducted or hydronic?
It depends on the design, the insulation, the heat source and how you use it. Zoning, well-sealed ducts, insulated pipes and good controls all bring running costs down, which is why we work it out from your plans rather than a rule of thumb.
When do I need to choose between ducted and hydronic?
Before the slab is poured if you want underfloor heating, and before the frame is lined for ducted heating, radiators or trench convectors. Your builder needs to know where pipes, ducts and units will go.
Your next step
Building new and torn between ducted and hydronic?Send us your plans andbook a free assessment. We will look at the slab, the ceiling space and how you live, and tell you straight which system suits, and what it needs from your builder and when. Not ready to talk yet?Take the 2-minute system finderfirst, or call 1300 139 177.

